The work we do, including prayer, praise, and thanksgiving, is so much fruit, produced by the Spirit in us as we discover how God’s mercy has made room for us.
The gospel reading assigned for Thanksgiving Day has always seemed to me an odd pericope. It comes off at first blush like Jesus is griping about not getting more credit for a miracle. Digging deeper, it can read like Jesus is shaming the kids for not sending a thank you note, with a side of racist tension to boot. It makes this gospel challenging to preach. Preacher, this is what makes it an important gospel lesson to get right and to deliver faithfully, especially on the occasion of a Thanksgiving service.
Context is a key factor in reading the ten lepers’ episode correctly, particularly when focusing (as on this occasion) on the “thank you” theme. Jesus teaches in the immediately preceding section that the Lord’s servants (douloi) serve from obligation, from duty, and without expectation of gratitude. “Does he thank the servant because he did what was commanded? So, you also, when you have done all that you were commanded, say, ‘We are unworthy servants; we have only done what was our duty’” (Luke 17:9-10). The dynamics of bondservant or slave to master are social. The relationship is clear. One is above and one is below. Work is not done as a matter of favor, freely. The work of the slave is done as a matter of obligation, of the bondservant as a matter of contractual requirement. The response to the discharge of duty is a transactional benefit. It is not a reward, but a wage, not a prize, but pay, not gratitude, but the expectation that duty is done. The response to favor on the other hand is not transactional, tit for tat, quid pro quo, even stevens in the universe. The response to favor is gratitude. And gratitude is a little more difficult to quantify than clock-in, clock-out wage calculation.
This is not to say we still do not try to run gratitude in the way of reciprocity. When I was a kid, my mom fought an on-again, off-again battle with me the weeks following Christmases and birthdays, attempting to instill an obligation in my head: When you get a gift you need to write a thank you note. This is, of course, a fantastic habit to catch. I am glad my mom did not outright lose that battle! But the heart and soul of it is not transactional. It is not rooted in a one-to-one correspondence or exchange value. It is rooted in something else entirely. It is rooted in love, in joy. The reading we are looking at this week for the Thanksgiving gospel is rooted in peace, reconciliation, healing, and salvation. Love, joy, and peace, it sounds like a cornucopia of fruit of the spirit that is running the gratitude show.
Preacher, beware. Do not turn this gospel into a lesson on manners! The sermon that goes, “Nine out of ten people forgot to say ‘Thank you.’ Don’t be one of them,” is not preaching the Gospel. That is extracting a moral lesson from the narrative and leaving the good news twisting somewhere along the travel narrative to Jerusalem. Worse yet, it risks making the gift of God sound like a transaction: God does something for you, and you owe Him something in return. God heals you, better show your appreciation. God blesses you, now you gotta’ write the “thank you” note. That is an extraordinarily impoverished account of grace and a remarkably poor way to preach Thanksgiving.
So, study the text, appreciate the text, and deliver the text. Notice, all ten are healed. Jesus does not withhold the gift from the nine because He knows they will not return. You can argue that Jesus says what He says in Luke 17:17-19 out of chagrin, but it would be harder to argue he is saying it out of astonishment or surprise. Jesus does not take their healing away. He is not a conditional gift-giver, waiting on their proper response to let the cure commence. No, He sends them to the priests, and as they go, they are cleansed. It is a gift already given and all ten receive. The Samaritan’s return does not purchase his healing, complete a transaction, or settle an outstanding account with Jesus. He has nothing to pay. He has received favor.
The Samaritan’s return does not purchase his healing, complete a transaction, or settle an outstanding account with Jesus. He has nothing to pay. He has received favor.
Notice, also, he is a Samaritan, the stranger, the outsider, the one who does not belong. The other nine may have a claim to the community of Israel, but not this guy. He is doubly alienated as a leper and a Samaritan (and as a student of Luke’s gospel, you know that is a double whammy which is right up the evangelist’s alley; Luke in particular zeroes in on gentiles, women, the poor, and the subaltern). The Samaritan is the one who recognizes the gift for what it is. He turns back, glorifies God with a loud voice, falls at Jesus’ feet, and gives thanks. The one who has no claim to the inheritance is the one who receives it. The stranger receives God’s mercy.
Take note, preacher, this is an image of the Gospel itself. We are not God’s people because we begin with a claim on Him. God is not the one under obligation! Nor do we make ourselves reconciled or worthy of reconciliation. We do not “holy” ourselves, approaching the altar with clean hands and perfect piety. We are, as Paul says, strangers and aliens who have been brought near (Ephesians 2:19). Those who were not a people have become God’s people (1 Peter 2:10). The righteousness by which we stand before God is not our own. It is alien righteousness. We have received a righteousness that comes to us from outside ourselves, from Christ, who gives us what we could never produce or claim on our own. Aliens like this Samaritan point us there.
We, like the Samaritan, do not return to Jesus with something to offer in exchange for what we received. He and we return because we receive something extraordinary. We return because the gift changes us. Jesus changes everything! The Samaritan’s thanksgiving is not a value exchange, not some price of admission to God’s favor. The Samaritan’s “thank you” is the fruit of having received God’s favor. Like the Samaritan, we do not make ourselves members of God’s household by giving thanks or any other such work we could do. The work we do, including prayer, praise, and thanksgiving, is so much fruit, produced by the Spirit in us as we discover how God’s mercy has made room for us.
Finally, notice Jesus’ final words to the man: “Rise and go your way; your faith has made you well” (or “your faith has saved you”). We are not just talking about physical ailments or penultimate remedies. Jesus’ cure is about more than social relations, relationships, or a return to ordinary social life. Jesus’ cure is salvation. It is peace. It is life with God that is freely given in Christ. Hear that, preacher, and you will hear a Thanksgiving gospel that is not chiefly about “being thankful.” It is about the God who gives. It is about the favor of God in Christ, bestowed on those who have no claim to it, who cannot repay it, who do not make themselves worthy of it. And it is about the peculiar joy of discovering that this favor is for you. Thanksgiving follows as fruit, and it overflows, just like the fruit in your cornucopia centerpiece. Thanksgiving is the fruit of faith that receives what God has given.
By all means, encourage your hearers to be grateful! Encourage them to write the “thank you” note, to recognize the kindness of others, to give thanks for daily bread, family, vocation, and all the good gifts of creation. But those exhortations cannot be the sermon for this text. The sermon to craft here is that God has had mercy on us. Christ has come to the unclean, the estranged, the outsiders, and made them His own. Then, having received such favor, what else is there to do but fall at Jesus’ feet and give thanks?